Proportionate Deterrence
Summary
The authors argue that U.S. nuclear policy should shift toward an 'existential threat policy' (ETP), using nuclear weapons only when no viable alternative exists to stop an existential attack. They recommend significant changes to the nuclear triad, including pausing the Ground-Based Strategic Deterrent (GBSD) ICBM program in favor of extending the Minuteman III, and canceling the nuclear-armed sea-launched cruise missile (SLCM-N). The report emphasizes the danger of 'entanglement' between conventional and nuclear command and control systems (NC3), which increases the risk of inadvertent escalation. It advocates for replacing 'launch under attack' (LUA) with 'decide under attack' (DUA) to provide presidents more time to verify warnings. Regarding arms control, the authors suggest extending New START and engaging China through strategic dialogues based on mutual vulnerability. Finally, they call for new studies on the climatic effects of nuclear war to inform targeting and yield decisions.
Key insights
- The authors recommend the United States adopt an 'existential threat policy' (ETP), declaring it would "use nuclear weapons only when no viable alternative exists to stop an existential attack against the United States, its allies, or partners."
- The report argues that the current U.S. declaratory policy of using nuclear weapons in "extreme circumstances" to defend "vital interests" is too vague and does not adequately convey the importance of proportionality.
- The authors propose replacing the 'launch under attack' (LUA) strategy with 'decide under attack' (DUA), which would allow a president to transmit orders with a time delay, enabling the cancellation or adjustment of strikes if a warning is proven false.
- The document recommends pausing the Ground-Based Strategic Deterrent (GBSD) ICBM program, estimated to cost $264 billion in lifetime costs, and instead extending the life of the current Minuteman III force.
- The authors advise canceling the nuclear-armed sea-launched cruise missile (SLCM-N), arguing it is redundant and could detract from the conventional missions of attack submarines.
- The report suggests maintaining the B-21 Raider, Long-Range Standoff (LRSO) weapon, and B61 nuclear bombs (the latter remaining forward-deployed in Europe until NATO requests removal).
- The authors recommend retaining the low-yield W76-2 warhead for Trident D5 missiles pending further analysis and briefings to Congress, noting it is preferred over higher-yield versions for humanitarian and legal reasons.
- The report identifies a risk of 'inadvertent escalation' caused by the 'entanglement' of nuclear and conventional command, control, and communication (NC3) systems, where cyber or kinetic attacks on conventional assets could be misperceived as precursors to nuclear war.
- The authors argue that the U.S. should extend the New START treaty, which was set to expire in February 2021, and pursue a follow-on agreement to further reduce deployed strategic delivery systems and warheads, potentially to a limit of 1,000.
- To engage China in arms control, the authors suggest the U.S. publicly acknowledge that its strategic competition with China is based on mutual nuclear vulnerability, rather than a strategy of preemptive counterforce.
- The report calls for the U.S. to commission the National Academy of Sciences to evaluate the climatic effects of nuclear war, specifically the risk of 'nuclear winter' and its impact on global food production.
- The authors suggest that the U.S. should design a prototype nuclear disarmament regime to demonstrate its commitment to Article VI of the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons (NPT).
Cite the original document
- APA
- Perkovich, G., & Vaddi, P. (2021). Proportionate Deterrence. Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. https://assets.carnegieendowment.org/static/files/Perkovich_Vaddi_NPR_full2.pdf
- Chicago
- Perkovich, George, and Pranay Vaddi. Proportionate Deterrence. Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, 2021. https://assets.carnegieendowment.org/static/files/Perkovich_Vaddi_NPR_full2.pdf.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |last1=Perkovich |first1=George |last2=Vaddi |first2=Pranay |title=Proportionate Deterrence |publisher=Carnegie Endowment for International Peace |date=2021 |url=https://assets.carnegieendowment.org/static/files/Perkovich_Vaddi_NPR_full2.pdf |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document carnend-003273)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{perkovich2021proportionate, author = {Perkovich, George and Vaddi, Pranay}, title = {{Proportionate Deterrence}}, institution = {Carnegie Endowment for International Peace}, year = {2021}, url = {https://assets.carnegieendowment.org/static/files/Perkovich_Vaddi_NPR_full2.pdf}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document carnend-003273} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated