Het EU-Mercosur handelsverdrag: een kritische analyse en een alternatief
Summary
The report by the Handel Anders! coalition argues that the EU-Mercosur trade agreement is a 'neokoloniaal product' that prioritizes multinational interests over environmental and human rights. It claims the deal will accelerate deforestation in the Amazon, Cerrado, and Gran Chaco, undermine the EU's 'Farm to Fork' strategy by exposing European farmers to unfair competition, and facilitate the displacement of indigenous peoples in Brazil, Argentina, and Paraguay. Economically, the authors argue the agreement promotes 'de-industrialisatie' in Mercosur countries by locking them into roles as raw material exporters. The document concludes by proposing an alternative trade framework based on UN multilateral cooperation, regional self-sufficiency, and enforceable rights for nature and workers.
Key insights
- The EU-Mercosur agreement is described as a 'neokoloniaal product' that exchanges high-value industrial goods from the EU for cheap raw materials and agricultural products—such as meat, soy, and biofuels—from Mercosur countries.
- The agreement is argued to be fundamentally incompatible with international climate goals, as it encourages the production of commodities that drive deforestation in critical biomes including the Amazon rainforest, the Cerrado, and the Gran Chaco region.
- European farmers face 'oneerlijke concurrentie' (unfair competition) because the deal liberalizes 82% of agricultural imports from Mercosur countries, allowing products produced under lower environmental, labor, and animal welfare standards to enter the EU market.
- The report claims the agreement will exacerbate the displacement of indigenous peoples and the violation of their land rights in Argentina, Brazil, and Paraguay, often involving violence and the ignoring of 'free, prior and informed consent' (FPIC).
- The agreement is expected to accelerate 'de-industrialisatie' in Mercosur countries by removing tariffs on strategic sectors like chemicals, pharmaceuticals, and automotive manufacturing, which may lead to the loss of approximately 186,000 skilled jobs in the region.
- The document identifies a significant 'democratisch tekort' (democratic deficit) in the negotiation process, noting that the European Commission led talks behind closed doors, excluding citizens, NGOs, and indigenous peoples while favoring multinational lobbies.
- Sustainability and human rights clauses in the agreement are criticized as being 'vrijblijvend' (non-binding) and unenforceable, lacking sanctions for governments that violate these provisions.
- The report argues that the EU's 'Farm to Fork' strategy is undermined by the trade deal, as the goal of reducing chemical pesticides and antibiotics is contradicted by the import of products from regions where such substances are used extensively.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Kelly, B., Middeldorp, N., de Strijcker, S., Postma, T., Deters, S., Geurts, G., & Murawski, S. (2021). Het EU-Mercosur handelsverdrag: een kritische analyse en een alternatief. Both ENDS. https://www.bothends.org/uploaded_files/document/Publication_EU-Mercosur_november_2021_Nederlands.pdf
- Chicago
- Kelly, Bruno, Nick Middeldorp, Sinde de Strijcker, Tjalling Postma, Sigrid Deters, Guus Geurts, and Sara Murawski. Het EU-Mercosur handelsverdrag: een kritische analyse en een alternatief. Both ENDS, 2021. https://www.bothends.org/uploaded_files/document/Publication_EU-Mercosur_november_2021_Nederlands.pdf.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |last1=Kelly |first1=Bruno |last2=Middeldorp |first2=Nick |last3=de Strijcker |first3=Sinde |last4=Postma |first4=Tjalling |last5=Deters |first5=Sigrid |last6=Geurts |first6=Guus |last7=Murawski |first7=Sara |title=Het EU-Mercosur handelsverdrag: een kritische analyse en een alternatief |publisher=Both ENDS |date=October 2021 |url=https://www.bothends.org/uploaded_files/document/Publication_EU-Mercosur_november_2021_Nederlands.pdf |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document bothends-000632)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{kelly2021het, author = {Kelly, Bruno and Middeldorp, Nick and de Strijcker, Sinde and Postma, Tjalling and Deters, Sigrid and Geurts, Guus and Murawski, Sara}, title = {{Het EU-Mercosur handelsverdrag: een kritische analyse en een alternatief}}, institution = {Both ENDS}, year = {2021}, month = oct, url = {https://www.bothends.org/uploaded_files/document/Publication_EU-Mercosur_november_2021_Nederlands.pdf}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document bothends-000632} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated