Could you pass me the sustainable pepper, please?
Summary
The report examines the complex, fragmented supply chain of spices, where approximately 90% of production is handled by smallholder farmers who act as price-takers. Using Indonesian pepper and Indian turmeric as case studies, it highlights critical sustainability gaps, including widespread pesticide poisoning, severe price volatility, and environmental degradation caused by monocultures and mining. It argues that the disconnect between international quality standards and local farm practices is driven by a lack of transparency and the dominance of intermediaries. The document proposes a step-wise roadmap for European companies to move from risk minimization to sector-wide sustainability principles, emphasizing long-term partnerships, responsible supply chain management, and the adoption of organic or Fairtrade certifications to secure supply and improve farmer livelihoods.
Key insights
- The spice supply chain is characterized by a high concentration of smallholder farmers who lack bargaining power and are typically price-takers. In Indonesia and India, about 90% of spices and herbs are cultivated by smallholders who often depend on multiple intermediaries—up to six between the farmer and the exporter—which reduces the farm-gate price and limits access to market information.
- There is a significant disconnect between the sustainability and quality requirements of international buyers and the actual practices on the ground. Farmers often refer to local grading norms based on sensorial aspects like size and color and are generally unaware of international standards, meaning there is no direct incentive to adopt sustainable practices without direct communication and incentives.
- Pesticide use in spice cultivation is frequently unwise and dangerous, leading to significant health risks for farmers. In Indonesian pepper plantations, 96% of pesticide applications are done in an unwise manner, resulting in 18% of farmers experiencing pesticide poisoning.
- Economic vulnerability is exacerbated by extreme price volatility and unfair trading practices. In Indonesia, approximately one-fifth of pepper farmers sell their produce at a fixed price prior to harvesting, often due to debts owed to traders who act as credit lenders, which can lead to bonded labour.
- Environmental degradation is linked to intensive farming and competing industries. In Bangka, Indonesia, the competition between white pepper farming and tin mining has led to monoculture practices that cause fertility loss and water pollution, making clean water for processing pepper scarce.
- Post-harvest losses are substantial, particularly for the primary producer. In the Indian turmeric supply chain, post-harvest losses average between 25% and 30%, with a large portion of these losses borne by the farmer.
- International processors face a 'smoke screen' created by traders and intermediaries, which hinders traceability and the ability to monitor sustainability at the farm level. This lack of transparency makes it difficult for buyers to ensure compliance with CSR principles or food safety standards.
- Organic and Fairtrade certifications offer a pathway to higher incomes, but barriers remain for the poorest farmers. Organic spices can command a 15-20% premium, but the cost of certification and lack of market linkages prevent many 'by default' organic smallholders from obtaining the label.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Pascale, G., & van Opijnen, M. (2010). Could you pass me the sustainable pepper, please? Both ENDS. https://www.bothends.org/uploaded_files/document/6Sustainable_Spices-_Boths_ENDS_-_Cordaid_-_CREM_-_October_.pdf
- Chicago
- Pascale, Guillou, and Marjon van Opijnen. Could you pass me the sustainable pepper, please? Both ENDS, 2010. https://www.bothends.org/uploaded_files/document/6Sustainable_Spices-_Boths_ENDS_-_Cordaid_-_CREM_-_October_.pdf.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |last1=Pascale |first1=Guillou |last2=van Opijnen |first2=Marjon |title=Could you pass me the sustainable pepper, please? |publisher=Both ENDS |date=October 2010 |url=https://www.bothends.org/uploaded_files/document/6Sustainable_Spices-_Boths_ENDS_-_Cordaid_-_CREM_-_October_.pdf |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document bothends-000446)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{pascale2010could, author = {Pascale, Guillou and van Opijnen, Marjon}, title = {{Could you pass me the sustainable pepper, please?}}, institution = {Both ENDS}, year = {2010}, month = oct, url = {https://www.bothends.org/uploaded_files/document/6Sustainable_Spices-_Boths_ENDS_-_Cordaid_-_CREM_-_October_.pdf}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document bothends-000446} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated