Second Review of the AFDB’s Independent Review Mechanism CSO Comments
Summary
The document outlines CSO critiques and proposed amendments to the African Development Bank's (AfDB) Independent Review Mechanism (IRM) Operating Rules and Procedures. It argues for greater independence through post-employment bans and external selection committees, increased transparency in document disclosure, and expanded effectiveness by including all human rights violations and private sector projects in the IRM's scope. The CSOs also advocate for lowering barriers to accessibility, such as allowing individual and non-local complainants and removing the requirement to use local grievance mechanisms first.
Key insights
- The CSOs argue that the IRM's independence is currently insufficient and recommend prohibiting the CRMU Director and IRM Experts from working at the AfDB after their terms expire to avoid conflicts of interest.
- To improve transparency, the CSOs recommend a clear section on information disclosure in the IRM rules, committing to publishing all relevant complaint documents online in a timely manner, including complaints, management responses, and final reports.
- The document argues that the IRM's effectiveness is limited by a narrow scope that only covers 'social and economic rights'; the CSOs demand that the mechanism be expanded to cover all human rights violations.
- The CSOs oppose the current distinction between public and private sector projects, arguing that the IRM should be able to determine compliance with any relevant operational policies for both, and that private sector loans should be conditional on agreeing to IRM jurisdiction.
- Using the Bujagali hydropower project in Uganda as a case study, the CSOs highlight that complaints can be extended indefinitely and recommend a strict time limit for handling and finalising IRM complaints.
- The CSOs identify significant barriers to accessibility, noting that from 1967 to 2013 the AfDB approved over 4,500 projects, yet only 9 complaints have been received and registered by the IRM.
- The document recommends removing restrictive eligibility criteria for filing complaints, specifically proposing that any individual or NGO (even those not directly affected) should be allowed to file, and that non-local representation should be permitted without needing to prove a lack of local representation.
- The CSOs disagree with a proposal to require complainants to use local grievance mechanisms before accessing the IRM, stating that such mechanisms often have an inherent conflict of interest and are not trusted.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Both ENDS (2014). Second Review of the AFDB’s Independent Review Mechanism CSO Comments. https://www.bothends.org/uploaded_files/inlineitem/1Aug30-2014_IRM_review_CSO_comments_FINAL.pdf
- Chicago
- Both ENDS. Second Review of the AFDB’s Independent Review Mechanism CSO Comments. 2014. https://www.bothends.org/uploaded_files/inlineitem/1Aug30-2014_IRM_review_CSO_comments_FINAL.pdf.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite press release |author=Both ENDS |title=Second Review of the AFDB’s Independent Review Mechanism CSO Comments |date=30 August 2014 |url=https://www.bothends.org/uploaded_files/inlineitem/1Aug30-2014_IRM_review_CSO_comments_FINAL.pdf |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document bothends-000346)}}
- BibTeX
- @misc{bothends2014second, author = {{Both ENDS}}, title = {{Second Review of the AFDB’s Independent Review Mechanism CSO Comments}}, publisher = {Both ENDS}, year = {2014}, month = aug, url = {https://www.bothends.org/uploaded_files/inlineitem/1Aug30-2014_IRM_review_CSO_comments_FINAL.pdf}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document bothends-000346} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated