BALANCING THE SCALES
Summary
The report examines the use of community protocols in four countries to address the impacts of extractive industries. It finds that while the processes vary in outcome—ranging from a publicly recognized document in Argentina to legal empowerment in India—they generally help communities unify their positions, increase legal knowledge, and engage more effectively with governments and companies. The document emphasizes that community ownership, local partnerships, and sufficient time are critical for success, noting that protocols can be productive even in environments with weak rule of law.
Key insights
- Community protocols can effectively reduce power imbalances by preparing communities to engage with external parties through the acquisition of project information, understanding of rights, and development of negotiation techniques.
- In Zimbabwe, the protocol process enabled the Marange community to negotiate with mining companies to designate sacred sites and ancestral graves as off-limits for mining and secure compensation for the relocation of other graves.
- The Argentinian process resulted in the public protocol document "Kachi Yupi: Tracks in the Salt," which received formal recognition from the Argentinian National Ombudsman in May 2016.
- Protocol processes can be effective for government engagement even in countries with weak rule of law and endemic corruption, as seen in Zimbabwe where the process led to interactions with parliamentarians and the Environmental Management Agency.
- Early engagement during the exploration phase is generally more effective and less pressured, as demonstrated in Argentina, whereas processes starting after project development (as in Kenya and India) often face greater internal community division due to conflicting economic interests.
- All four pilot processes resulted in increased legal empowerment, enabling communities to use national and international laws to demand compensation or request project information.
- The protocol process in India highlighted the risk of exacerbating internal conflict if facilitators select participants without adequate community input or impose external objectives, as occurred in the first phase involving the Paudibhuyan and Munda tribes.
- The development of a comprehensive, inclusive public protocol document is a resource-intensive, multi-year endeavor; the fastest process in the study (Argentina) took 21 months.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Makagon, J., von Braun, J., Cocchiaro, G., & James, S. (2016). BALANCING THE SCALES. Heinrich Böll Stiftung Southern Africa. https://za.boell.org/sites/default/files/balancing_the_scales.pdf
- Chicago
- Makagon, Jael, Johanna von Braun, Gino Cocchiaro, and Stella James. BALANCING THE SCALES. Heinrich Böll Stiftung Southern Africa, 2016. https://za.boell.org/sites/default/files/balancing_the_scales.pdf.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |last1=Makagon |first1=Jael |last2=von Braun |first2=Johanna |last3=Cocchiaro |first3=Gino |last4=James |first4=Stella |title=BALANCING THE SCALES |publisher=Heinrich Böll Stiftung Southern Africa |date=December 2016 |url=https://za.boell.org/sites/default/files/balancing_the_scales.pdf |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document boellza-000103)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{makagon2016balancing, author = {Makagon, Jael and von Braun, Johanna and Cocchiaro, Gino and James, Stella}, title = {{BALANCING THE SCALES}}, institution = {Heinrich Böll Stiftung Southern Africa}, year = {2016}, month = dec, url = {https://za.boell.org/sites/default/files/balancing_the_scales.pdf}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document boellza-000103} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated