What wrong with Eskom and how to fix it
Summary
The document analyzes the failures of Eskom, attributing load shedding and debt to neglected maintenance, corruption, and a contradictory 'commercialised' mandate. It critiques the South African government's plan to 'unbundle' Eskom into separate generation, transmission, and distribution entities, arguing this will lead to higher prices and privatization. Instead, the authors propose a 'Transformed Eskom'—a de-corporatised public utility led by workers and communities, funded through wealth taxes and pension fund surpluses, to manage a 'just transition' to renewable energy.
Key insights
- Eskom's inability to produce sufficient electricity, leading to load shedding, is driven by a failure to build new power plants and the neglect of maintenance. The document notes that Eskom warned of the need for new capacity as early as 1998, but government efforts to involve the private sector failed because electricity prices were too low to attract profit.
- The utility is trapped in a 'debt trap' with approximately R480bn in debt, requiring R31.2bn annually just for debt-related costs. While municipal debt (R46.1bn in 2020) is a factor, it represents less than 10% of total debt; the primary drivers are the rising cost of coal, corruption, and mismanagement, including R178 billion in 'dodgy' contracts.
- The authors argue that 'commercialisation' (corporatisation since 2002) has ruined Eskom's finances by forcing a public utility to operate like a private company. This creates a contradiction where Eskom must provide affordable, reliable electricity as a mandate while simultaneously pursuing 'full cost recovery' and profit.
- South Africa's energy sector is heavily reliant on coal, which generates over 91% of its energy, contributing to high carbon intensity and local health crises, including over 2,000 premature deaths per year due to air pollution.
- While renewable energy costs have dropped to R0.70/kWh—making them cheaper than new coal—the authors argue that private Independent Power Producers (IPPs) prioritize profit over essential needs and employ unskilled, temporary workers with fewer benefits than the public sector.
- The government's plan to 'unbundle' Eskom into three separate companies (Generation, Transmission, and Distribution) is viewed as a path toward privatization. The authors claim this will create a 'death spiral' where the Transmission entity must raise prices to cover the 'system costs' of variable renewable energy, similar to trends observed in Germany.
- A 'Transformed Eskom' is proposed as the only viable way to achieve a 'just transition.' This model involves de-corporatising the utility, removing 'user-pays' principles, establishing worker councils, and treating electricity as an essential public good rather than a commodity.
- Funding for this transformation could be sourced from a wealth tax on the top 1% (potentially R160bn/year), curbing illicit financial flows (estimated at R200bn/year), and utilizing the Public Investment Corporation/Government Employee Pension Fund (GEPF), which could potentially free up R800bn.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Baigrie, B., Oelofsen, J., & Rudin, J. (2021). What wrong with Eskom and how to fix it. Alternative Information & Development Centre. https://aidc.org.za/download/AIDC-Eskom-QA-Booklet-Final-digital-1.pdf
- Chicago
- Baigrie, Bruce, Jaco Oelofsen, and Jeff Rudin. What wrong with Eskom and how to fix it. Alternative Information & Development Centre, 2021. https://aidc.org.za/download/AIDC-Eskom-QA-Booklet-Final-digital-1.pdf.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |last1=Baigrie |first1=Bruce |last2=Oelofsen |first2=Jaco |last3=Rudin |first3=Jeff |title=What wrong with Eskom and how to fix it |publisher=Alternative Information & Development Centre |date=May 2021 |url=https://aidc.org.za/download/AIDC-Eskom-QA-Booklet-Final-digital-1.pdf |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document aidcza-000111)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{baigrie2021what, author = {Baigrie, Bruce and Oelofsen, Jaco and Rudin, Jeff}, title = {{What wrong with Eskom and how to fix it}}, institution = {Alternative Information \& Development Centre}, year = {2021}, month = may, url = {https://aidc.org.za/download/AIDC-Eskom-QA-Booklet-Final-digital-1.pdf}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document aidcza-000111} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated